Прислано Sedat Canbaz 23-06-2014 13:36
#323
I've just calculated the current played games with 4 different calculation programs
Note: Crafty 24 x64 is fixed to 2900 Elo points
And as we see not only the chess engines,
even the calculation programs are different to each other... ))
And now I have a question to all:
- Which is the most accurate rating list ??
And under the current conditions, which chess engine is stronger:
- Gull or Stockfish ??
Btw, all games are available for downloading:
http://www.sedatc...age_id=522
Код
A) Ordo 0.8 Calculation:
# PLAYER : RATING POINTS PLAYED (%)
1 Gull 3 x64 : 3387.1 593.5 660 89.9%
2 Stockfish 210614 x64 : 3385.2 577.5 631 91.5%
3 Stockfish 140614 x64 : 3375.0 482.0 530 90.9%
4 Senpai 1.0 x64 : 3096.8 456.5 661 69.1%
5 Texel 1.04 x64 : 3095.1 455.0 657 69.3%
6 Protector 1.6.0 x64 : 3071.9 443.0 663 66.8%
7 DiscoCheck 5.2 64 : 2996.3 386.5 662 58.4%
8 Booot 5.2.0 x64 : 2956.8 356.0 660 53.9%
9 MinkoChess 1.3 x64 : 2913.7 326.5 661 49.4%
10 Crafty 24 x64 : 2900.0 314.5 661 47.6%
11 Scorpio 2.7.7 x64 : 2863.5 285.5 658 43.4%
12 EXchess_v7.26a : 2848.5 272.5 660 41.3%
13 Arasan 17.2 x64 : 2845.4 271.5 665 40.8%
14 Octochess r5190 x64 : 2839.4 266.5 659 40.4%
15 Cheng4 0.36c x64 : 2838.7 265.0 662 40.0%
16 Rodent 1.4 x64 : 2789.6 228.5 660 34.6%
17 Bobcat 3.25 x64 : 2762.5 210.5 658 32.0%
18 Bison 9.11 x64 : 2752.7 201.5 661 30.5%
19 Redqueen 1.1.97 x64 : 2691.9 161.0 662 24.3%
20 Cyrano 0.6b17 x64 : 2681.6 153.5 660 23.3%
21 Pawny 1.0 x64 : 2673.8 149.0 661 22.5%
--------------------------------------------------------------------
B) Bayeselo 0056 Calculation (mm 1 1):
Rank Name Elo + - games score oppo. draws
1 Gull 3 x64 3331 33 31 660 90% 2910 13%
2 Stockfish 210614 x64 3323 34 32 631 92% 2892 13%
3 Stockfish 140614 x64 3321 37 34 530 91% 2894 14%
4 Senpai 1.0 x64 3080 23 23 661 69% 2924 24%
5 Texel 1.04 x64 3080 23 23 657 69% 2921 26%
6 Protector 1.6.0 x64 3056 23 22 663 67% 2923 27%
7 DiscoCheck 5.2 64 2993 22 22 662 58% 2930 27%
8 Booot 5.2.0 x64 2954 22 22 660 54% 2932 28%
9 MinkoChess 1.3 x64 2914 22 22 661 49% 2931 30%
10 Crafty 24 x64 2900 22 22 661 48% 2934 31%
11 Scorpio 2.7.7 x64 2868 22 22 658 43% 2933 27%
12 EXchess_v7.26a 2853 22 22 660 41% 2937 27%
13 Arasan 17.2 x64 2849 22 22 665 41% 2939 29%
14 Octochess r5190 x64 2846 22 22 659 40% 2936 31%
15 Cheng4 0.36c x64 2846 22 22 662 40% 2939 29%
16 Rodent 1.4 x64 2798 22 23 660 35% 2938 26%
17 Bobcat 3.25 x64 2771 23 23 658 32% 2936 25%
18 Bison 9.11 x64 2758 23 23 661 30% 2944 22%
19 Redqueen 1.1.97 x64 2702 24 24 662 24% 2943 21%
20 Cyrano 0.6b17 x64 2694 24 24 660 23% 2944 22%
21 Pawny 1.0 x64 2687 24 25 661 23% 2943 21%
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
C) Elostat 1.3 Calculation
Program Elo + - Games Score Av.Op. Draws
1 Stockfish 210614 x64 : 3293 37 36 631 91.5 % 2879 13.5 %
2 Stockfish 140614 x64 : 3281 40 39 530 90.9 % 2881 13.6 %
3 Gull 3 x64 : 3277 35 35 660 89.9 % 2896 13.5 %
4 Senpai 1.0 x64 : 3049 24 24 661 69.1 % 2909 23.8 %
5 Texel 1.04 x64 : 3047 24 24 657 69.3 % 2906 25.6 %
6 Protector 1.6.0 x64 : 3030 24 23 663 66.8 % 2909 27.1 %
7 DiscoCheck 5.2 64 : 2973 23 23 662 58.4 % 2914 27.3 %
8 Booot 5.2.0 x64 : 2943 23 23 660 53.9 % 2916 27.9 %
9 MinkoChess 1.3 x64 : 2910 22 22 661 49.4 % 2915 30.4 %
10 Crafty 24 x64 : 2900 22 22 661 47.6 % 2917 30.7 %
11 Scorpio 2.7.7 x64 : 2870 23 23 658 43.4 % 2917 26.9 %
12 EXchess_v7.26a : 2859 23 23 660 41.3 % 2921 27.4 %
13 Arasan 17.2 x64 : 2857 22 22 665 40.8 % 2922 29.3 %
14 Octochess r5190 x64 : 2852 22 22 659 40.4 % 2919 31.4 %
15 Cheng4 0.36c x64 : 2851 23 23 662 40.0 % 2922 28.7 %
16 Rodent 1.4 x64 : 2810 24 24 660 34.6 % 2921 25.6 %
17 Bobcat 3.25 x64 : 2788 24 24 658 32.0 % 2919 25.1 %
18 Bison 9.11 x64 : 2782 25 25 661 30.5 % 2926 22.2 %
19 Redqueen 1.1.97 x64 : 2728 26 26 662 24.3 % 2925 20.8 %
20 Cyrano 0.6b17 x64 : 2719 26 26 660 23.3 % 2927 21.7 %
21 Pawny 1.0 x64 : 2711 26 27 661 22.5 % 2925 20.6 %
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
D) Fritz 12 GUI Calculation:
1 Stockfish 210614 x64 3290
2 Stockfish 140614 x64 3279
3 Gull 3 x64 3274
4 Senpai 1.0 x64 3047
5 Texel 1.04 x64 3046
6 Protector 1.6.0 x64 3029
7 DiscoCheck 5.2 64 2972
8 Booot 5.2.0 x64 2942
9 MinkoChess 1.3 x64 2910
10 Crafty 24 x64 2900
11 Scorpio 2.7.7 x64 2870
12 EXchess_v7.26a 2859
13 Arasan 17.2 x64 2857
14 Octochess r5190 x64 2852
15 Cheng4 0.36c x64 2851
16 Rodent 1.4 x64 2810
17 Bobcat 3.25 x64 2788
18 Bison 9.11 x64 2782
19 Redqueen 1.1.97 x64 2728
20 Cyrano 0.6b17 x64 2720
21 Pawny 1.0 x64 2711
And here is the Round-Robin table:
Редактировал Sedat Canbaz 23-06-2014 13:38